Biodiverse agriculture as part of a food-secure future
But there鈥檚 an important downside to this trend, argues Timothy Johns, Professor of Human Nutrition at 麻豆AV in Montreal, in a paper presented Feb. 15 at the annual meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science in Chicago.
Diets for most people around the world are becoming increasingly limited in biological and nutritional diversity. 鈥淟arge-scale agriculture is characteristically simplified and less diverse than small-holder agriculture,鈥� Prof. Johns cautions. 鈥淭his is true in genetic, ecological and nutritional terms.鈥澨�
Small farmers, by contrast, in many places continue to grow a range of species and multiple varieties that form the basis of their diet and nutrition. Use of a range of wild species of fruit, vegetables, condiments and medicines, as well as wild animal-sourced foods, increase the likelihood that subsistence farmers with access to natural ecosystems meet their nutrition and health needs.
The problem is that smallholder farmers in developing countries often have low productivity and little likelihood of generating the profits needed to rise above poverty level, says Prof. Johns, who directs the 麻豆AV Canadian Field Studies in Africa program. In particular, the smallholder farms in sub-Saharan Africa, which account for more than 90% of agricultural production and the primary livelihood of 65% of the population, need to be more productive.
When they have access to improved technology, however, smallholder farmers can be both more productive and more sustainable than large-scale, intensive agriculture.听Using family members in farming reduces labor and supervision costs, while a more intimate knowledge of the local soil, plants and animals enables smallholders to maximize output.听 In Brazil, for example, national data from the Censo Agropecu谩rio shows that 鈥渇amily farms鈥� produce 38% of national agricultural value from 24% of the agricultural land. An assessment of 286 projects in 57 countries, moreover, shows that low-cost, sustainable and diversity-enhancing technologies increased average crop yields on small farms by 79% since the early 1990s.
Recognizing the value of particular elements of agrobiodiversity with exceptional nutritional and health properties can provide opportunities where smallholder farmers have economic advantages, Prof. Johns argues. Access to such products offers potentially profound public health benefits, he adds. 鈥淧roducts of biodiversity within culturally-based diets provide essential micronutrients and lower prevalence of diet-related chronic disease.鈥�
Carbohydrates 鈥� mainly cereals, sugars, potatoes and other tubers 鈥� and vegetable oils produced efficiently by large-scale agriculture and distributed through global trade are more affordable for many people than lower-calorie, more nutritious foods. In many cases, the result is a form of malnutrition defined by overconsumption of calories. This has helped fuel a growing global epidemic of obesity and chronic diseases such as diabetes and cardiovascular disease.听
Meanwhile, some 2 billion people suffer from deficiencies in micronutrients, most importantly iron, vitamin A, iodine and zinc. This typically results from not eating enough foods rich in essential vitamins and minerals, such as animal-source foods, fruits, vegetables and legumes.
Socially guided food-policy decisions should value the environmental, health, social and cultural benefits offered by agrobiodiversity, Prof. Johns argues. One example of this approach: Brazil鈥檚 National School Feeding Law and program since 2009 requires that at least 30% of food in the program must come from family agriculture. It also has explicit guidelines for the use of healthy food in school menus, including foods that respect the culture and traditions; and it provides incentives for the purchase of diversified foods, preferably from local family agriculture.
鈥淔ood-policy makers around the world should seek to develop novel compensation mechanisms that reflect the benefits of small-scale, biodiverse agriculture,鈥� Prof. Johns says. 鈥淭his may involve direct subsidies to farmers, but it must also involve investment in extension services, infrastructure, supply-chain research and development, and progressive market regulation.鈥�
听
PHOTO:听Women smallholder farmers in Kenya
Wikimedia Commons听(McKay Savage from London, UK)
听
听
